FIGURE IT OUT
Protect Your Medicare Rights.
When you become eligible for Medicare, two doors open that require no health exam — no medical history, no underwriting, no questions about pre-existing conditions. This tool shows you exactly where your doors stand today, and which Medigap plan makes financial sense for your situation.
PART 1 OF 2
Two Open Doors
Federal law gives every Medicare beneficiary two guaranteed-issue windows — periods when private insurers cannot ask about your health history or deny you coverage. Most people never hear about them until it's too late.
The Medigap Open Window
A federal protection giving you the right to buy any Medigap plan — including Plan G — without answering a single health question. The federal window is 6 months from your Part B start date. Many states extend it with birthday rules or year-round protections.
The Medicare Advantage Test Drive
If you enrolled in Medicare Advantage when you first became eligible, federal law gives you a 12-month trial period. During that window you can drop the Advantage plan, return to Original Medicare, and buy a Medigap plan — guaranteed, no health questions. This right exists once.
CHECK YOUR WINDOWS
Answer a few questions. We'll show you exactly where your doors stand today.
STATE PROTECTIONS AT A GLANCE — 2026
| Protection Type | What It Gives You | States (2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Year-round guaranteed issue | Switch Medigap anytime, no health questions | CT, NY, VT |
| Year-round equal-or-lesser | Switch anytime to equal or lesser benefits | WA, ME |
| Annual expanded window | Feb 1–Mar 31 each year | MA |
| Birthday rule (16 states) | Annual window around your birthday | CA, DE, ID, IL, IN, KY, LA, MD, MO*, NV, OK, OR, UT, VA, WV, WY |
| Coming January 2027 | Birthday rule begins | NM |
| Federal baseline only | 6-month window from Part B start date | All other states |
*Missouri uses a policy-anniversary date, not a birthday, with a 63-day window. Rules change — always confirm with SHIP or your state insurance department.
PART 2 OF 2
Plan G vs. Plan N: Which Costs Less for You?
Both plans cover the same major bills. The difference is how you pay for routine care. This calculator shows which plan is likely cheaper based on how often you use healthcare — and flags the one risk factor Plan N doesn't cover.
- Pay the Part B deductible once a year ($257 in 2026)
- $0 copays for all doctor visits after that
- $0 hospital coinsurance
- Covers Medicare excess charges
- Higher monthly premium
- Pay the Part B deductible once a year ($257 in 2026)
- Up to $20 copay per doctor visit
- Up to $50 copay per ER visit
- Does not cover Medicare excess charges
- Lower monthly premium — typically $30–$60 less than Plan G
BREAK-EVEN CALCULATOR
Enter your age and how often you see a doctor. We'll show you which plan costs less over a full year.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
The Medicare Truths You Need to Know
What exactly is the Medigap Open Window — and why does it close?
When you first enroll in Medicare Part B, federal law gives you a six-month window during which private insurers must sell you any Medigap policy — including Plan G — without asking a single question about your health history. They cannot charge you more for pre-existing conditions, and they cannot deny you.
After that window closes, insurers in most states can use medical underwriting. That means they can review your health history, charge higher premiums based on your conditions, or decline to cover you at all. The window exists precisely because Congress recognized that people need a protected entry point into Medigap — but it only works if you know about it and use it in time.
I keep seeing ads for "$0 premium" Medicare Advantage plans. How can a plan be free?
The $0 premium refers only to the monthly amount you pay directly to the insurer. It does not mean the plan is free. The federal government pays private insurance companies a fixed monthly subsidy — set by CMS — for every Medicare beneficiary they enroll. That payment model means insurers are compensated per enrollee regardless of how much care you actually use.
Insurers use a portion of that subsidy to fund extras like gym memberships or basic dental, which are the benefits most prominently advertised. The trade-off is that Advantage plans use private networks, require prior authorization for many procedures, and have out-of-pocket maximums that can reach $9,350 or higher in-network — and up to $14,000 out-of-network for PPO plans. The $0 premium is real. The "free" framing is not.
What is the 12-Month Trial Right and how do I use it?
The Trial Right is a federal consumer protection that applies specifically to people who enrolled in Medicare Advantage when they first became eligible for Medicare. If that describes you, you have exactly 365 days from your Advantage plan's start date to change course.
During that window, you can drop the Advantage plan, return to Original Medicare, and buy a Medigap plan — with guaranteed approval, no health questions. After the window closes, this specific right expires. You can still switch plans during the Annual Enrollment Period (October 15 – December 7), but the guaranteed-issue Medigap right does not apply. Use the calculator above to find your exact deadline.
If Plan G and Plan N cover the same things nationwide, why does my ZIP code change the price?
The federal government standardizes Medigap benefits — a Plan G sold in Texas covers the same bills as a Plan G sold in Maine. What it does not standardize is the premium. Private insurers set premiums based on local factors: average hospital costs in your county, local cost of living, and the competitive landscape in your market.
High-cost metropolitan areas generally have higher baseline premiums than rural markets. Insurers also use different rating methods — some charge everyone the same rate regardless of age (community-rated), some increase premiums as you age (age-attained), and some set your premium based on your age when you first enrolled (issue-age). The rating method matters as much as the initial premium when projecting long-term costs.
What is the difference between Plan G and Plan N?
Both plans cover hospital coinsurance, the Part A deductible, skilled nursing facility coinsurance, and foreign travel emergency care. The difference is in how you pay for routine outpatient care.
Plan G covers everything after the annual Part B deductible ($257 in 2026) — no copays for doctor visits, no coinsurance, and no exposure to Medicare excess charges. Plan N has a lower monthly premium — typically $30–$60 less than Plan G — but charges up to $20 per doctor visit and up to $50 per ER visit. Plan N also does not cover excess charges, which are fees some providers charge above the Medicare-approved rate. Use the break-even calculator above to see which plan costs less based on how often you use healthcare.
Can a broker or agent legally not mention these windows to me?
Yes — through omission. Agents are legally prohibited from making false statements, but they are not required to proactively explain multi-year financial risks, the 12-Month Trial Right, or state birthday rules during a sales conversation. The regulatory framework governs what agents cannot say, not what they are obligated to cover.
Because Medicare Advantage plans typically pay higher upfront commissions and ongoing renewal commissions than Medigap plans, agents who work on commission have a structural incentive to focus on Advantage enrollment. That does not make every agent acting in bad faith — many are genuinely helpful. But it does mean the information you receive in a sales context is shaped by the compensation structure of the person delivering it. The Clearing exists specifically to fill that gap.
WHAT THE SALES PITCH LEAVES OUT
Four Medicare Advantage Trade‑offs Worth Understanding
Medicare Advantage plans work well for many people. The question is whether you're choosing one with a complete picture of the trade-offs. These four factors are rarely covered in a standard sales conversation — not because agents are required to hide them, but because the conversation tends to focus on what the plan offers rather than how it works when you need it most.
Prior Authorization
On Original Medicare, if your physician orders a procedure, you receive it. On Medicare Advantage, the insurer must approve many procedures before they're covered — a process called prior authorization. The Kaiser Family Foundation found that Advantage plans denied 6.6% of prior authorization requests in 2021. Most denials are eventually overturned on appeal, but the process takes time, and time matters in healthcare.
Network Instability
Advantage plan networks are private contracts between insurers and providers. Those contracts can change mid-year. If your specialist, hospital, or cancer center leaves the network after you've enrolled, you cannot switch plans until the next Annual Enrollment Period — October 15 through December 7. Original Medicare has no network. Any provider who accepts Medicare accepts you.
Out-of-Pocket Maximum
Medicare Advantage plans are required to cap your annual out-of-pocket costs, but the cap can reach $9,350 in-network and up to $14,000 out-of-network for PPO plans (2026 CMS limits). Plans marketed as PPOs — which sound like they allow any provider — often apply significantly higher cost-sharing when you use out-of-network facilities. Original Medicare has no annual out-of-pocket cap, which is why most people pair it with a Medigap plan.
Extra Benefits vs. Core Coverage
Dental, vision, hearing, and gym memberships are real benefits — but they typically come with annual caps, often $500–$1,000 total, and significant restrictions on what's covered. They are funded by the same CMS subsidy that also covers your medical care. The question worth asking before enrolling: how does this plan perform when I have a serious illness, not when I need a gym membership?
The Clearing does not recommend or sell any Medicare plan. This information is based on publicly available CMS data, KFF research, and federal law. Our goal is to give you the complete picture so your decision is genuinely yours. Take the Fit Check to see which path fits your situation →
Want to think through the full picture with Fern?
Fern is The Clearing's AI guide — no sales pitch, no commission, no agenda. She can walk you through what these windows and plan differences mean for your specific situation.