← All Medicare tools
Free tool · no email to start

Plan G, High-Deductible G, or Plan N — which way of paying fits you?

If you've decided on a Medigap policy, the next question feels technical — Plan G, High-Deductible Plan G, or Plan N? It's simpler than it looks. There's no "best" one; there's the one that fits how you'd rather pay.

The part nobody tells you plainly: these are the same coverage. Medigap plans are standardized by law — every insurer's Plan G covers exactly what every other Plan G covers. So the choice isn't about what's covered. It's about two things, and we keep them separate below: what you pay every month (premium), and what you pay only when you get care.

The shape of the trade

Standard Plan G

Pay more monthly
Every month — premium
Highest of the three
Only when you get care
A flat $283 a yearthe Part B deductible — then essentially nothing, all year
Fits you if you want the most predictable costs and would rather pay steadily than ever face a surprise bill.

Plan N

In between
Every month — premium
Lower than Plan G
Only when you get care
$283 a year, plus small copaysup to $20 a visit, up to $50 for ER (waived if admitted); doesn't cover "excess charges"*
Fits you if you want a lower premium than G, don't mind small copays at visits, and your providers accept Medicare's rate.

High-Deductible Plan G

Pay less monthly
Every month — premium
Lowest of the three
Only when you get care
$283 in a good year — up to $2,950 in a bad oneyou cover your Medicare costs up to $2,950, then it pays everything
Fits you if you're comfortable trading a much lower premium for a bigger bill in a rough year — and have savings to cover it if it comes.
The bet, in one line Standard G buys predictability — the highest premium, but care is a flat $283 all year. Plan N sits in the middle: a lower premium, with small copays when you get care. High-Deductible G has the lowest premium, but trades it for the risk of owing up to $2,950 in a heavy year — you're wagering the premium you save against that gap.
Have your quotes? See it in your own dollars

Premiums vary a lot by age, state, and insurer, so enter the monthly premiums you've actually been quoted. We'll fill the same two rows — premium and care — with your numbers, and show the bet as a figure. Leave any blank to skip it; this is optional.

* "Excess charges" are when a provider bills up to 15% above Medicare's approved amount. They're uncommon — about 97% of providers accept Medicare's rate — and eight states ban them entirely. You can avoid them by asking whether a provider accepts Medicare assignment.

You can see the trade-off. Now what?

The numbers narrow it down, but the right call depends on your health, your savings, and how you feel about a surprise bill — a conversation, not a calculation.

A few things these numbers don't capture: Plan N's copays add up if you see doctors often; rare "excess charges" aren't included; and premiums can change each year — and may involve health questions if you switch plans later. Whether any of these apply to you depends on your health, your providers, and your savings — which is exactly what Fern can weigh with you.
Consult further with Fern
Weigh this against what the numbers can't see — your health, your savings, whether your doctors take assignment, and how a surprise bill would land for you.

Ask Fern something like

Consult further with Fern
Keep a copy
We'll email this comparison so you have it when you're ready — no spam, no sales calls.

Please enter a valid email address.

✓ On its way. Check your inbox — and your spam folder, just in case.

Common questions about Medicare Supplements

What's the difference between Plan G and Plan N?

Both are Medigap plans that pay most of what Original Medicare doesn't. Plan G covers nearly everything after the Part B deductible; Plan N has a lower premium but leaves you small copays at some visits and the ER, and doesn't cover the rare “excess charges.” The trade is a lower monthly cost against a little more you pay as you go.

What is High-Deductible Plan G?

It's the same coverage as standard Plan G, but you pay a much lower premium and cover your own costs up to a yearly deductible before it kicks in. It suits people who want catastrophic protection at the lowest monthly cost and can handle the deductible in a bad year.

Are all Plan G policies the same?

The coverage is, because Medigap is standardized by law. What differs between companies is the premium and how they raise it over time, plus customer service — which is why it's worth comparing rather than assuming they're identical.

For the build team — verification & maintenance notes (remove before ship)

Refined reference build of Tool 2. Logic & copy are the verified deliverable, carried over verbatim from the prototype (Medicare.gov / CMS + Fact Log, June 2026). Rebuild in Astro with real Brevo + analytics + server validation; this file is the behavior + design spec.

Hard rules preserved

Verified figures (2026) — isolated in ANNUAL, tied to the Fact Log

Integration points (stubbed here — wire for real)

Honesty + a11y (keep in Astro)

New · Read the book →